Elektrine lite

← Feed

@flick@spinster.club

2026-09-19 20:03 UTC

MI6, the Secret Intelligence Service, did not give Burnham an emphatic ‘Don’t do it’ message, but it outlined that it could risk intelligence-sharing with Israel. ‘People in 6 are pulling their hair out,’ says an influential Labour figure close to the security services. ‘They presented warnings about the consequences of doing this.’ That source even suggests that Sa’ar only took Miliband’s call after a request was passed on by MI6 via Mossad. Netanyahu routinely refuses to talk to British politicians. A non-political source with deep roots in the intelligence community has this to say: ‘If you appear like a lightweight who will selectively virtue-signal, you’re not going to be taken seriously again.’ He says that Mossad already views MI6 as competent but overcautious: ‘The relationship was difficult because we did national security, the Israelis do national survival. I think the Israelis see us as pretty professional, but a bunch of pussies in terms of the methods that we would use.’ What does less cooperation mean in practice? My sources are adamant that if Mossad had actionable intelligence about an Islamist attack in the UK, they would still pass it on. But those who understand the nuances of the intelligence-sharing relationship are clear that useful information will be lost at the margins. ‘If it’s a real, imminent national security threat, they tell us,’ a second intelligence source says. ‘But they won’t just give us a flow of information like the Five Eyes’, the intelligence-sharing partnership which comprises the UK, US, Canada, Australia and New Zealand. ‘Everything is conditional and transactional.’ Lost Israeli intelligence cannot easily be replicated by Britain’s Gulf Arab allies. ‘The Israelis are light years ahead of all the Arab services,’ the second intelligence source adds. But in Whitehall it is little understood that Miliband’s decision has also damaged relations with Gulf Arab states, which rely on intelligence passed to MI6 by the Israelis. This is an element with which Blaise Metreweli, the chief of MI6, would be very familiar, having served in Oman. ‘The Gulfies come to us because they know that we have a good relationship with Israel and they know that basically they’re getting Israeli product,’ a security source says. ‘They can’t get it directly, but they want it, they need it. They’re looking at us going, “What the fuck are you doing falling out with them?” A Labour source who spoke recently to senior figures in Qatar, Saudi Arabia and the UAE says: ‘Not one of them thinks we have gained influence from this. They just think we’re increasingly irrelevant. The Saudis and Qatar are downgrading their investments in the UK.’ Powell’s marginalisation is also a problem, since he was playing a key role in advising Middle East actors. The senior Labour figure I spoke to says: ‘The bigger concern was that Jonathan, someone they respected, has now become an auxiliary figure in the government. They like Jonathan because he’s a brain and he knows so many situations, what works, how you do mediation… Jonathan has a sense of strategic national interest and this [decision] is a purely domestic-driven initiative.’ Some Labour figures have been encouraged by the muted reaction to the sanctions from the White House, seeing that as good news for Burnham’s upcoming meeting with Donald Trump. But those who have recently been in Washington say this is not approval, but a measure of Britain’s irrelevance. ‘I’ve spoken to members of the administration and they have no regard for the UK government,’ says a source just back from D.C. ‘There’s a resigned indifference.’ Given all this, why did Miliband drive the issue with the same zeal he showed in championing net zero? In the Commons, Miliband presented his decision in the context of his family history as the grandson of Holocaust survivors. In an interview with Alastair Campbell and Rory Stewart, released on Tuesday, he explained that his decision to accuse Israel of ‘war crimes’ and ‘ethnic cleansing’ came from conversations with his mother before she died in May: ‘My mum… lost her father [and] 60 relatives in the concentration camps… I wrestled a lot with what she would say. And she’d say: “Look at what is happening to Palestinians… It’s wrong, and you’ve got to call it out.”’ Those who know him say he is personally ‘very hostile’ to Israel and was less comfortable when visiting the country than his brother, David. Some in the Jewish community believe Miliband is purposefully building up rivals to the Chief Rabbi, who publicly criticised the sanctions as a threat to the safety of the Jewish community in Britain. These rival groups include the Movement for Progressive Judaism and Yachad, which advocates for a political solution to the Middle East conflict. ‘He’s pushing to go further and further to do more and more, and people feel he’s crossed a line,’ says a prominent member of the community.

Replies (1)

  • @flick@spinster.club 2026-09-19 20:03

    Security officials say Miliband is also less temperamentally inclined to listen to the spooks. ‘He has never been a massive admirer of the intelligence services,’ says a source who served in the secret service under the last Labour government. ‘I remember when he was in government before. He was a very clear contrast with his brother. He was known to be suspicious of the intelligence agencies.’ To be clear, holding pro-Palestinian views alongside deep hostility towards the Israeli government is a mainstream position in the Labour party. Added to this, there lurks a suspicion of Israel among the ‘camel corps’ in the Foreign Office, including both younger diplomats and intelligence officers. My first intelligence source says: ‘There’s always been a kind of T.E. Lawrence mystical fascination with Arab culture and Muslim culture, and a disdain for Israel, and by extension for Jews, who are seen as a bit too like them – a bit too white, a bit too bourgeois, a bit too trade, a bit too clever, a bit too hard-working.’ However, it is understood that even senior Foreign Office officials agreed with the ambassador in Tel Aviv that now was not the right time to act. In both the Foreign Office and MI6 the great division is between age groups. ‘There’s a generational fight inside the Foreign Office between those who care about our strategic national interest and the campaigners,’ says the senior Labour source. The first intelligence source says the culture is also changing inside MI6 to accommodate younger, impassioned officers. No one doubts that the policy is popular domestically, but the question is whether Burnham and Miliband’s desire to proceed with it ought to have been outweighed by the first duty of government, which is national security – not least given the fallout may have strengthened Netanyahu’s chances of re-election, and that the two-state solution remains as remote as it has been since Yasser Arafat rejected it in 2000. ‘This is not a business for people who want to be purer than pure,’ a former cabinet minister says. ‘This is a business for people who want to protect Britain.’

    Open ##4967617