Elektrine lite

← Feed

@Seleni@lemmy.world

2026-10-31 06:52 UTC

Eeeehhh the ending was a little… Like, the author said she wanted to make it as depressing as possible to drive home the point that war is bad. And yeah, I agree war is really, really bad, and plenty of people never really recover from it. But at the same time plenty of people do, and go on to live at least decent lives. Some of them even turn what they went through into something inspiring. I doubt The Lord of the Rings would have been half as good without JRR Tolkien’s experiences in WWI, for example. I think that exploring both those themes, and what it takes to come back to yourself after the horrors of war, would have been more poignant. And I also feel that perhaps showing a way through that darkness for at least some of the characters might have been better than the message ‘war sucks and since you got involved you’re going to suffer and have a shitty life forever with no possible escape from the pain but death, fuck you’.

Replies (2)

  • @macji@pawb.social 2026-10-31 07:10

    I think it’s fair to say after all these 13 year olds (!) have been through, return to happiness is rather safely out of the question. I agree with you that that’s a hopeful and sweet theme, but I rather appreciate her willingness to say, no, sometimes things, and people, just break under terrible circumstances beyond their control. The tragedy is that it had to happen at all, that the invasion forced them to become heroes when they were only children. But with their sacrifice and heroism, from which they could have easily walked away at any time but didn’t, humanity is saved and the awful slavery of the yeerks is ended not just for humans but for everyone. But they did too much, and while it was necessary and worth it, it’s a tree they planted whose shade they’ll never see and which cost them everything. Sometimes it’s just not okay. And that to me, while sad, is far more than stories that bend over backwards to make it all okay. There’s a place for both, and Animorphs is not hopeless or gritty grimdark just to be edgy, I actually think it’s full of hope that the war could be ended at all, with such good outcomes for the galaxy, and against such odds, and with the heroes they happened to have on hand. But it’s not free or without consequence.

    Open ##5378302

  • @hakase@lemmy.zip 2026-10-31 12:12

    She specifically did do that though. Like, it was a whole big deal that one of the characters came out the other end able to heal and do great things afterwards.

    Open ##5383176