Elektrine lite

← Feed

@toolbear@tech.lgbt

2026-09-13 00:46 UTC

@ewjoachim@piaille.fr "I'll just pirate it" in the case of JKR is a way of culpability-washing one's consumption of problematic media. It isn't about harm reduction. It certainly isn't about solidarity against fascists, it's the opposite of that. It's scab behavior. It's "watch all the problematic stuff you want with this one weird trick" wishcasting. Consuming Harry Potter whether paid for in money still pays Rowling. It absolutely grows the market. It keeps her relevant. It normalizes her and her work and her terrible ideas. And frankly, I don't believe most folks who say they didn't pay for it. They're lying to try and dodge judgement and shaming. "I hand out pirated photocopies of Mein Kampf…I'm virtuous, actually." It's shameful to not take one of the most obvious moral stands available to us today. It doesn't get more black and white than this. The ethics around JKR and HP specifically are clear cut in the present day. @chaoddity@mastodon.social @ScottEdelman@wandering.shop

Replies (1)

  • @ewjoachim@piaille.fr 2026-09-13 07:17

    @toolbear@tech.lgbt @chaoddity@mastodon.social @ScottEdelman@wandering.shop Hm, Mein Kampf is a problematic work even independently from its author much more than Harry Potter is. Not denying, in Harry Potter, the antisemitic tropes of goblins, the "everyone is white except for a single token chinese pupil" etc, but that's nowhere near the amount of bigotry the author exhibits. If somehow JKR lost the rights to the franchise and it was taken over by trans-friendly people and stopped beneffiting JKR completely, consuming HP content would probably bu much finer (though staying mindful of aformentioned tropes). Being a fan of Mein Kampf even though the author is dead is much, much more problematic.

    Open ##5400197